No Country for Gay Men Kirill Filimonov 20/11/2011 Opinion & Analysis While Estonian government is considering legalisation of same-sex marriages, Russian politicians start a big anti-gay campaign. This week, St. Petersburg local parliament passed a law that forbids “homosexual propaganda”, equating it to pedophilia agenda. It was earlier approved by Ryazan and Arkhangelsk regional parliaments. Moscow is ready to follow suit. Meanwhile the ruling party’s representatives are suggesting that such a law should be passed in the State Duma, the federal parliament Gay activists arrested in Moscow | Photo: en.rian.ru Although Russia has a reputation of a country that does not tolerate homosexuality, the rights of LGBT (lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender people) were not violated officially yet. There was an attempt to ban “homosexual propaganda” (or homosexual appeal, as it is called in the US) back in 2003, but this law was rejected by the State Duma. Now the position of the politicians seems to have changed, probably due to a visible shift in the public opinion. The Russians are incredibly homophobic. Last year’s Levada Centre polls reveal that 38% of people regard homosexuality as “dissoluteness and a bad habit”, 36% think it is a “disease”. These points of view are becoming increasingly popular. Only 15% think this is just another sexual orientation that “has the same right to existence”, five per cent less than five years ago. More and more people think that homosexuals need to be “treated” (21%), “isolated from the society” (18%), and even “liquidated” (4%). 84% oppose same-sex marriages, and 82% are not going to tolerate gay pride parades in Russian cities. “A gay parade cannot be called anything but a Satanic act”, ex-Mayor of Moscow Yury Luzhkov said last year, supposedly voicing the common opinion. While homophobia in the United States has a religious basis, the reasons are different in Russia. According to Gallup polls, only one third of Russians say religion is an important part of their daily life as against two thirds of Americans. Hence it is patriarchal character of Russia that is the key factor of homophobia. They can let lesbian women be, but gay men are undergoing a huge pressure. You are supposed to correspond with the picture of a “real man”, muzhik – butch, strong, and even brutal. Otherwise you risk being despised. For most of the Russians, gay men are not men at all. Apart from patriarchal nature of the country, LGBT issues in Russia should be considered as a part of a whole tolerance problem. Half of the nation, for instance, want ethnicity section back in their passports. It was first introduced in the USSR as a method of ethnic discrimination, and abolished after the democratic revolution of 1991. Since the idea is popular again, different political groups try to profit from the nationalistic mood with slogans like “Let’s defend ethnic Russians” (in contrast to the Tatars, the Chechens, etc.), including the Communist party and populist LDPR. Admittedly, neither the society nor the authorities have ever seemed to care about minority issues. Such kind of care is a feature of liberal democracy. However, when the Russian government sequentially suppresses the rights of numerous social groups including minorities, it would be illogical if the rights of LGBT were respected. Similarly, when the Russian citizens accept regular violation of human rights, it would be rather strange if they stood up for homosexuals. It is therefore no wonder that such laws are passed right now. There are only two weeks left before Election Day to the State Duma and St. Petersburg local parliament. Humbling gay, lesbian, bisexual and trangender people seems to be an easy and a sure way to gain support of Russian voters. It won’t be just swallowed, it will be welcomed. 4 Responses feetxxxl 20/11/2011 surely equating homosexuality, the bonding of 2 adults out of mutual love, devotion,affection,trust and respect for a shared committed life together, with homophelia, the sexual violation of children, is something out of the dark ages. is russia trying to prove that one can be a capitol society and still be backword an repressive at the same time? Reply Doug M 20/11/2011 Then what is found, when the layers are peeled away, is that often the leadership of the Russian GLBT intolerance/hatred movements, will in fact be deeply self-loathing, repressed, closeted Russian men in terrible sham marriages. Who are projecting their psychological dysfunction outward as a means to rationalize the life of self denial they are living. Reply Petra L 29/01/2012 WOW… terrible to read this and oddly enough I am watching the treatment of Jews in Latvia during the second world war..it is so SAD to see how little we evolve as a people/species/culture on this planet and how incapable we are for and to love…. or seemingly so.. we live in such fear… and of what? absolute craziness, there must be a little Nazi in all of us wanting to persecute others for being different even in this day and age. Reply bill 27/03/2012 Good on Russia to stay clean, wish other leaders had those kind of moral understandings. Reply Leave a Reply Cancel Reply Your email address will not be published. Name* Email* Website Comment Comment moderation is enabled. Your comment may take some time to appear. Notify me of follow-up comments by email. Notify me of new posts by email.